Toast POS Complaints, Lawsuits & BBB Reviews: What Seattle-Tacoma Restaurant Owners Should Know
Choosing a Point of Sale (POS) system is one of the most important technology decisions a restaurant owner will make. While cloud-based POS systems such as Toast have gained significant market share in recent years, prospective buyers should understand not only the features and benefits of a platform but also any documented controversies, customer complaints, and legal issues associated with it.
At National Business Systems, Inc., we believe business owners deserve transparent information when evaluating POS solutions. This article reviews publicly documented complaints, controversies, and legal matters involving Toast that restaurant operators should consider before signing a long-term agreement.
The 2023 Online Ordering Fee Controversy
In 2023, Toast faced significant criticism from restaurant owners after implementing a 99-cent processing fee on certain online orders. According to reports, restaurant owners argued the fee was added without their approval and that customers blamed the restaurant for the additional charge rather than Toast.
Following substantial pushback from restaurant operators and public scrutiny, Toast ultimately rescinded the fee and removed it from its online ordering channels.
For many restaurant owners, the incident raised concerns about how much control they maintain over their online ordering platform when using a cloud-based provider.
Better Business Bureau Complaints
The Better Business Bureau (BBB) profile for Toast, Inc. shows a substantial number of customer complaints. The BBB's analysis highlighted recurring concerns in several areas, including:
- Billing disputes and refund concerns
- Customer service issues
- Service quality concerns
- Hardware support and maintenance complaints
- Resolution and response time concerns
The BBB reports hundreds of complaints over recent years. Toast has responded publicly stating that it continually updates its customer support, billing processes, and service procedures in response to customer feedback.
Mandatory Payment Processing
One frequently discussed topic among restaurant owners is Toast's payment processing requirement.
According to Toast's own documentation, merchants using Toast must use Toast's payment processing services and cannot utilize an alternative third-party processor. Toast specifically states that customers cannot run another processor alongside Toast Payments.
For some operators this may not be a concern. However, others prefer the flexibility to shop for competitive processing rates, negotiate fees independently, or retain their existing payment processor relationship.
If you're considering a Toast POS system, you may also find value in reading our analysis of recent fee increases and payment processing concerns affecting restaurant operators:
This article examines how payment processing fees can affect restaurant profitability and why many Washington restaurant owners are taking a closer look at their POS and merchant service options.
Businesses considering Toast should carefully evaluate whether they are comfortable with a processor-specific platform before making a commitment.
Data Breach Investigations
In 2025, Toast disclosed a security incident involving certain payroll users.
Following the disclosure, multiple law firms announced investigations into potential class-action litigation regarding the incident. Public reports indicate that information potentially involved in the breach may have included combinations of:
- Social Security numbers
- Financial account information
- Driver's license information
- Email addresses
- Dates of birth
- Phone numbers
Several legal firms continue to provide information regarding potential claims and investigations related to the incident.
What Does This Mean for Restaurant Owners?
Every POS provider faces customer complaints and legal challenges at some point. The more important question is whether a system's business model aligns with your restaurant's needs.
Before selecting any POS platform, restaurant operators should ask:
- Am I comfortable with a processor-specific payment platform?
- What are the cancellation terms?
- Will I own my hardware?
- What happens if I want to switch providers later?
- How much control do I have over pricing and customer-facing fees?
- What level of local support is available?
These questions can save significant frustration and expense down the road.
Local Support Matters
Many Seattle and Tacoma area restaurants appreciate having a local technology partner they can call when something goes wrong. While cloud-based systems offer many advantages, businesses should carefully evaluate support options, processing requirements, contract terms, and total cost of ownership before making a decision.
A POS system should help your business grow, not create unexpected surprises.
Looking for a Toast Alternative?
National Business Systems, Inc. offers restaurant and retail POS solutions ranging from traditional electronic cash registers to advanced cloud-based POS platforms. We help Washington business owners compare Toast, Square, SAM4s, Cash Register Express, and other leading solutions so they can make an informed decision.
Whether you're opening a new restaurant, replacing an aging POS system, or simply evaluating alternatives, our team can help identify the right solution for your needs and budget.
For more information call 800-863-2274 or visit www.nbsystems.com.
About National Business Systems, Inc.
National Business Systems, Inc. has been helping restaurants and retailers throughout the Seattle-Tacoma region and across the United States select the right POS systems, cash registers, payment processing solutions, receipt printers, barcode scanners, and business technology solutions for decades.
Whether you are evaluating Toast, Square, SAM4s, Cash Register Express, or other POS platforms, our goal is to help you make an informed decision based on your business requirements, budget, and long-term goals.
National Business Systems, Inc.
Phone: 800-863-2274
Website:
www.nbsystems.com
For expert guidance on restaurant POS systems, merchant services, and cash register solutions, give us a call today.
Sources
-
Toast Billing FAQ (Processor Requirement)
https://support.toasttab.com/en/article/Toast-Billing-FAQ -
BBB Complaints Profile for Toast, Inc.
https://www.bbb.org/us/ma/boston/profile/point-of-sale-systems/toast-inc-0021-164973/complaints -
Fox Business: Restaurateurs Fuming Over New Fee Billed to Customers by Toast
https://www.foxbusiness.com/lifestyle/restaurateurs-fuming-ominous-new-fee-billed-customers-big-tech-vendor -
Fox Business: Toast Rescinds Fee Following Restaurant Backlash
https://www.foxbusiness.com/lifestyle/mom-pop-restaurant-revolt-forces-big-tech-vendor-toast-rescind-fees-american-diners -
ClassAction.org Toast Data Breach Investigation
https://www.classaction.org/data-breach-lawsuits/toast-july-2025 -
Barnow and Associates Toast Data Breach Investigation
https://www.barnowlaw.com/toast-inc-data-breach-investigation/